Navigating the Pitfalls of Merchant Cash Advances: A Personal Journey
If you’ve ever found yourself caught in the cycle of high-cost merchant cash advance (MCA) loans, you’re not alone. Despite being a business finance professional who should have known better, I’ve been there too.
My story is a testament to the allure of quick cash solutions and the dangerous traps that can come with them. Here’s how it unfolded for me and how you can avoid making the same mistakes.
The Allure of Merchant Cash Advances
Merchant cash advances offer what many small business owners desperately need: quick access to cash.
When traditional bank loans seem out of reach, especially for those with less-than-perfect credit, MCAs promise a fast solution with minimal paperwork.
For me I had excellent credit at the time but I had fallen behind on my financials and I know we weren’t profitable at the time either as we were going through a downturn in our top line and I had been irresponsible in not cutting costs as quickly as I should have.
These MCA loans offer funding within days, using your future credit card sales and/or your future revenues as collateral, making them a seemingly convenient option for business owners facing urgent cash flow issues.
The Temptation of Quick and Easy Money
For many small businesses, especially those struggling with cash flow, the promise of immediate funds can be irresistible.
Merchant cash advances work by purchasing a portion of your future sales, allowing the lender to collect repayments directly from your daily credit card transactions. This structure can seem manageable initially, especially when business is booming and sales are steady.
It started when my business hit a slow period. I had already taken a couple of MCAs in the past, paid them off, and moved on.
They had served their purpose during those times, providing quick cash when traditional loans weren’t an option These MCA loans offer funding within days, using your future revenues/income as collateral, making them a seemingly convenient option for business owners facing urgent cash flow issues.
I thought I could handle it again. But each time I took another advance, I was playing with fire.
Understanding the True Cost of Merchant Cash Advances
What makes merchant cash advances so appealing is also what makes them risky. They’re marketed as quick and easy, often sidestepping the traditional loan criteria and providing funds with lightning speed.
However, this speed comes at a cost. MCAs are notorious for their high-interest rates, often expressed as factor rates, which can make the actual cost of borrowing much higher than a conventional loan from a traditional bank. Quite frankly, much higher than about any other form of borrowing a small business can do.
There’s nothing more costly than these…and have your radar up because they also pay commercial loan brokers high commissions. Remember what happened with the subprime mortgage space? Can you say Global ripple effects! Well, the SMB space is smaller but because this space is unregulated, the MCA brokerage business is subprime mortgage lending 2.0.
High Costs and Hidden Dangers
The real cost of MCAs isn’t just the high-interest rates; it’s the daily or weekly repayments that can severely impact your business’s cash flow.
Payments are often automatically deducted from your business’s bank account based on your credit card receipts, leaving little room for flexibility if sales dip or unexpected expenses arise. This inflexible repayment schedule can quickly become a burden, especially during slow sales.
I learned this the hard way. After dodging the bullet several times, I took out a third MCA, thinking I could manage it as I had before. But things were different this time.
The repayments were relentless, eating into my daily revenue and making it increasingly difficult to cover other essential business expenses. The pressure was on, and it wasn’t just financial—it was emotional too.
The Emotional and Operational Toll of High-Cost Debt
Taking on high-cost debt like MCAs doesn’t just strain your business finances; it takes a toll on you. The constant pressure to keep up with daily repayments can lead to sleepless nights, stress, and even strained relationships.
As a business owner, this financial burden often falls squarely on your shoulders, affecting your decision-making and overall outlook.
Facing the Lies We Tell Ourselves
As entrepreneurs, we’re often driven by optimism and resilience. We believe in overcoming challenges and growing our businesses, even when the odds are stacked against us. For me, this optimism became a double-edged sword.
I convinced myself that our past successes would continue, that growth was inevitable, and that we’d make it through despite the challenges. But sometimes, that optimism blinds us to reality.
I told myself that taking another MCA was the right decision because I didn’t want to face the hard truth: our business was slowing down, and I needed to make tough decisions.
I didn’t want to cut costs or lay off staff—I didn’t want to disappoint my team. But by avoiding these decisions, I made things worse. I took on more debt, hoping things would turn around, but instead, I found myself in a deeper hole.
The Risks of Ignoring Warning Signs
Merchant cash advances can seem easy but rarely the best long-term solution. The initial appeal can quickly fade as the reality of daily repayments sets in.
Without careful planning and a clear repayment strategy, MCAs can lead your business down a precarious path, not only negatively impacting your cash flow but it makes it tough to make payroll and pay yourself. Get on that treadmill and I’ve seen it cause other business owners to make other poor decisions that a clear-thinking individual would never make.
The Reality of High-Cost Business Loans
MCAs are often marketed as flexible and fast financing solutions for businesses that can’t qualify for traditional small business loans due to factors like bad credit or inconsistent cash flow.
In most scenarios, the benefits end there. If you borrow $50,000 for example, with a traditional business loan you would have a monthly payment of about $650. That would be the same as $150/week. With that same $50,000 as a business cash advance or MCA your weekly payment would likely be about $2,500. $150 vs $2,500.
Finding a Path Forward: Understanding Your Options
If you’re stuck in the cycle of high-cost debt, the most important step is understanding your options.
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed, but there are ways to regain control of your business finances. The first step is acknowledging the situation and seeking help from trusted advisors who can guide you through your options.
Exploring Alternative Financing Options
One of my biggest mistakes was not exploring other financing options sooner. While traditional bank loans may seem out of reach, other alternatives can provide the funds you need without the crippling costs associated with MCAs.
Options like business term loans, revolving credit lines, and invoice factoring can offer more manageable repayment terms and lower interest rates.
Steps to Take When Facing High-Cost Debt
-
Assess Your Financial Situation: Look closely at your cash flow, expenses, and overall financial health. Understanding where your money is going and where you can cut back is crucial in managing debt. Get outside the box on this one. Do you really need that salary to Bobby and is the (fill in the blank) position REALLY needed?
-
Explore Debt Consolidation…?: It depends on what this means. If you have multiple MCAs, consolidating them into a single loan with a lower interest rate could simplify your repayments and reduce the financial strain. That’s kind of a given…BUT if you mean a reverse MCA consolidation then those almost never work and I advise against those 95-99% of the time. Then the other “consolidation” option of holding funds in escrow with a 3rd party also is something that some consider but while this does work on the consumer side it is NOT recommended on the small business side because these MCA loan companies will file judgments against you while you’re freezing them out and thinking you may be able to settle with them later. Not a good idea.
-
Negotiate Repayment Terms: While MCA lenders are often inflexible, it’s worth exploring whether they will negotiate the repayment schedule, especially if your business is struggling. Keep in mind that a business owner simply cannot do this as well as a trained and experienced restructure team. Yes it belongs on the list but renegotiating on a business cash advance is a skill that is best administered by a qualified third party.
-
Consider Alternative Financing: Look into other funding options, such as traditional bank loans, SBA loans, or even business credit cards, which might offer better terms. This is something 99% of you would have already done if you were able to so, again, not going to be a “real” option for most of you reading this if you have multiple advances and are needing to solve a cash flow challenge you’re facing.
-
Seek Professional Advice: A financial advisor or business consultant can provide valuable insights and help you navigate the complexities of managing high-cost debt. My experience here is that the really good ones are hard to find. Good advise but be sure your “advisor” knows the options you have and ask if they’ve been through it first hand – cough cough 🙂
Our blog about the 6 options for getting out of MCA and high-cost debt is coming soon so watch for it.
Learning and Moving Forward
Looking back, I learned the importance of not letting fear drive financial decisions. I let my fear of disappointing my team and my overly optimistic outlook cloud my judgment. But as entrepreneurs, we have to be realistic and make tough decisions for the sake of the business.
There’s Always a Way Out
It took time, but I eventually found my way out of the mess with the help of the right people advisors who knew the landscape and could guide me through the options. If you’re facing similar challenges, know that there is hope. Restructuring your debt, finding new financing, or making strategic cuts to your expenses are all wise and that’s just the beginning.
I plan to write more about the six key options for getting out of high-cost business debt soon because these options aren’t widely known and can be confusing.
In the meantime, remember that you’re not alone, and there’s always a path forward, even if it’s unclear. Don’t lose sight of your goals and dreams. Trust me there’s hope, and there’s a way out.
Tom Gazaway
[email protected]